One of my all time favorite mountaineering films. Much better than the crap you see in Vertical Limit or Cliffhanger (Doug despised both those films.)
The technical parts are very authentic. You really get a sense of what mountaineering is like.
You will see the beautiful vistas, feel the blowing wind, get thirsty when they suffer from dehydration, and feel the fear.
The movie is about a disastrous climb on the
20,813 foot Siula Grande mountain the Peruvian Andes. Most accidents happen on the way down, which is what occurred in this case. It is an incredible story of human character tested to its limits. You can't make this stuff up.
It is told in the climber's own words. No moralizing, No judgments. Just brutal honesty. They both admit to some things they thought and did that are
not pretty.
Things to think about while you watch the film:
- W
hat would you have done in Yates' situation? (Unless you have been there or done that, it is hard to say)
-
How would you live with the decision Yates made? (See
Living with guilt and thoughtworms)
-
What would you do to survive? How would you maintain hope?
-
Would you keep climbing after an experience like this? ( Both of these men continued to climb after this incident, although not together.)
The two principals - Joe Simpson (author of the equally good book of the same name) and Simon Yates were 25 and 20 at the time of the incident (1985.) They were climbing companions vs. great friends.
Both Simpson and Yates were involved in the filming. Simpson experienced some post traumatic stress after returning to the location. He happy with the resulting film. He wrote the book to vindicate Yates' decision, which he has always defended. Yates was roundly criticized by some in the climbing community.
Three parts really resonated for me. One was how Simspon set interim goals to make progress and survive. It makes you think anything is possible. Another was the ability to not be judgemental, which reminded me of Doug. And a third was what he went through. I thought if he could survive that, maybe I can survive a broken heart.
I also thought the
earworm part (where a crummy song by Boney M gets stuck in Simpson's head) was interesting - you could feel how annoying it was. (I struggle with
thoughtworms.) I actually felt sick during the part where he was hallucinating.
The film was shot mostly in the Peruvian Andes and some in the European Alps. Simpson and Yates and a third (non-climbing companion) Hawkins narrate the film. The climbing re-enactments are done by other actors.
By the way, their summit has not been repeated. Another group took a different, safer approach in 1999 and made it to the summit. They named the route "Avoiding the Touch."
I recommend that you read the book and watch the movie. It is an amazing, thought provoking story.